The Pros & Cons of 4 Different Roofing Materials

5-star rated

Schedule Your Home Inspection!

Home » Our Blog » The Pros & Cons of 4 Different Roofing Materials

If your home needs a new roof, you should first consider the different roofing materials available. Various roofing materials each have their unique pros and cons that can significantly influence your decision.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Different Roofing Materials

Let’s look at the advantages and disadvantages of four popular roofing materials: asphalt shingles, wood shingles, tiles, and metal roofing.

Asphalt Shingle Roofs

Asphalt shingles are affordable and readily available in a variety of colors. They are the most common of all the different roofing materials. Fiberglass-based asphalt shingles are also Class A fire-resistant and can withstand a fire for as long as two hours. However, other roofing materials are superior to asphalt if you live in an area prone to forest fires. 

The biggest disadvantage of asphalt shingles is that they have a relatively short lifespan when compared to other roofs. Asphalt shingles should last anywhere from 15 to 30 years, but some other types of roofs can last 50 years or longer. Asphalt shingles are prone to wind and storm damage. It’s not uncommon for asphalt shingles to blow off during severe winds. 

Wooden Roofing Materials

Wooden shingle roofs tend to last a bit longer than their asphalt counterparts, at about 30-40 years. The lifespan of wood shingles depends on the type of wood, the thickness of the shingles, and your local climate. Wood roofs are aesthetically pleasing, with an organic, natural look. They also weigh less than some other types of roofing material.

One disadvantage is that wooden shingles are more expensive than some roofing materials. Also, they should periodically be treated with a fire retardant and may even be banned in your area due to fire concerns. Wooden shingles also need occasional treatment with fungicides and preservatives to keep the shingles from warping, cracking, drying out, and growing mold and mildew.

Metal Roofs

The biggest advantage of a metal roof is a lifespan of up to 60 years. Special coating treatments and factory paint will also increase the roof’s lifespan. Metal roofs can be made from aluminum, steel, or copper, and come in a wide variety of colors and styles. Furthermore, adding a metal roof is a good way to increase your home’s value. Metal roofing is also very fire resistant. As a result, choosing a metal roof can also lower your home insurance rate, especially in states that experience frequent wildfires.

The big disadvantage to a metal roof is the higher cost, both for the materials and for the installation. 

Tile Roofing

Tile roofing is very attractive and gives your home an exotic, Mediterranean appeal. Another big advantage is that the tile roofing is non-combustible. Tile roofs are also rot and pest-resistant, and have a long lifespan, lasting for at least 100 years. A tile roof can also reduce your monthly energy bill since ceramic and concrete have energy-saving attributes.

The disadvantage of a tile roof is two-fold: the cost and the weight. Tile roofs are very expensive and heavy. A tile roof can put a strain on the structural integrity of your house. If your house wasn’t built with a tile roof, it’s important to discuss adding this type of roof with a structural engineer.

A licensed roofing contractor will be able to help you determine the best roofing material for your home, budget, and local climate.  Additionally, if you needed a trusted resource in Raleigh home inspections or roofing inspections then call a certified home inspector.

Steve Smallman Property Inspections provides home inspection services to the North Carolina Triangle. Contact us to book an appointment.

Property Inspection Services
Serving Raleigh & The Triangle




Steve Smallman Property Inspections, LLC is pleased to offer these specialized inspection services to our customers.


If you’re the first-ever occupant of your brand-new home, you have specific inspection needs before moving in. We inspect your new home before your final walkthrough to add an objective set of experienced eyes to help protect your investment. We also do pre-drywall inspections.


New homes may come with a warranty that lasts a year. An 11-month inspection is key in terms of taking advantage of what your warranty guarantees. We check for anything covered by your warranty before it expires so that the proper party is responsible for any repairs.


Selling a home? A pre-listing inspection gives you an advantage. Letting us identify maintenance needs before you sell lets your home enter the market in its very best state free from defects that could cause potential buyers to turn away from what could be a golden opportunity for everyone.


Life moves so quickly that general and even significant home maintenance can sometimes be forgotten. Furthermore, some routine home maintenance items are difficult to spot without the proper experience. Let our highly-trained inspectors give your home a check-up and help you prioritize regular home maintenance to save money and to help keep your family safe.


Termites and other wood-destroying insects cause millions of dollars of damage per year to buildings all over North Carolina. Our inspectors are all Registered Pest Control Technicians with the NC Department of Agriculture Structural Pest Control Division. We are affiliated with Cooper Pest Control to provide the wood-destroying insect reports (WDIR) required by many mortgage lenders.


Radon – an odorless, colorless gas – naturally occurs in most soil. It’s also the leading cause of lung cancer among non-smokers in North America. We can perform the EPA-recommended radon testing that determines whether or not you are being exposed to safe levels of radon within your home.

More to explorer

Steve Smallman Inspections

Safe Stairs, Avoid Falls!

Good stair construction is something home inspectors look for, and we report safety hazards when found. Safety hazards can include, but are not limited to,

Read More »